To See Consent Crushed Before Us: The Lamentations Of Nerd Women (Redux)


I’ve already touched on the extra-special bundle of harassment that us nerdy female types have to deal with in-game, but this recent article by The Mary Sue serves as an alarming reminder that the creepers aren’t all confined to the basement — some of them are disguising themselves as “respectable journalists” and walking among us, leaving a trail of skeev and sense of extreme discomfort in their wake.

In essence, a group of cosplayers portraying Lara Croft at this past PAX East were accosted by a so-called journalist and his cameraman, in what at first seemed like a regular interview.  Cosplayer Lauren Wizemann recalls:

We were taking pictures in the booth and then we moved out towards the walkway so that people walking by could see a group of Lara Crofts. We took more pictures and then this guy comes up and asks if he could ask a few questions. His partner had a more professional looking camera and so I think all of us just shrugged and said ok.

Things quickly took a turn for the inappropriate when the interviewer asked “How does it feel to  be at a convention where none of the men could please you?”  Megan Marie, another cosplayer involved with this incident, describes her reaction on her Tumblr:

My anger flared upon hearing this, and for a moment I almost let it get the best of me. I attempted to calm myself down before walking towards him and the cameraman, and expressing that it was rude and unprofessional to assume that these young women were comfortable discussing sexual matters on camera. I intended to leave the conversation at that, but his subsequent response escalated matters quickly and clearly illustrated that this ran much deeper than a poor attempt at humor. He proceeded to tell me that “I was one of those oversensitive feminists” and that “the girls were dressing sexy, so they were asking for it.” Yes, he pulled the “cosplay is consent” card.

When informed of the incident, PAX East was quick to respond and assured that the journalist in question would no longer be welcome at their events — a heartening display, on their part, of a much-needed dedication to making sure that attendees feel safe and comfortable within its walls.  Unfortunately, I couldn’t find any mention of the interviewer’s name or the publication he worked for, so there’s no telling if this was a major nerd-news outlet who could potentially remove him from their ranks, or just another example of a creepy guy with a personal blog who’ll just continue to harass women and then throw a temper tantrum when told “not cool, bro.”  I’m not sure about PAX East’s guidelines for obtaining a press pass to their event, but I know that some conventions and industry gatherings have historically required nothing more than a fansite to qualify, meaning that accountability for one’s actions is not always an option.

This guy’s statement that if a girl dresses sexy, she’s asking for harassment, is something that sends a chill down my spine.  It’s the same rationale used by date rapists all over the world.  I’m not saying that if he had offered these cosplayers sodas, they would have definitely been spiked with something, but if he’s already got this mentality in place just for face-to-face interactions with others, what the Hell is stopping him from applying it to something even worse?

How dare a woman dress provocatively, whether in her daily life or for a special occasion?  In the eyes of this dude and so many others like him, if we want to be sexy, this is the price we have to pay.  If we speak up, we’re the bitches, the whores, the teases, the insert-terrible-name-for-a-woman-who-exercises-her-right-to-say-no.  If we had only chosen to wear a T-shirt and jeans and no makeup that day, we wouldn’t have had to endure it.

Another troubling school of thought is that in the case of women who do choose more revealing cosplays, they’re only “doing it for attention” or playing right into this “male fantasy” I keep hearing so much about.  I’ve seen and heard these statements being thrown around not just by men, but by women, as well.  In truth, I find it to be one of the most oppressive and offensive things you can say for a few reasons:

  • By addressing the “male fantasy,” you’re completely ignoring lesbians and anyone not fitting into “traditional” gender roles, such as those who identify as neither male nor female or the intersexed;
  • You are assuming that women are silly naive little flowers who can’t make their own decisions on something as simple as what to wear without being consciously or subconsciously influenced by outside sources;
  • You are perpetuating the stereotype that the only way to be a “feminist” or achieve equal rights is to deny our own femininity altogether, and any woman even touching a tube of lipstick is sending us all back to the Dark Ages.

It’s the same thing as people who can’t keep their mouths shut about cosplayers who are overweight or who they perceive as unattractive — if you don’t like the way that somebody is dressed, don’t talk to them.  Don’t invite them out for coffee, don’t smile at them, don’t ask them to be the godparent of your fifth child.  You are  not obligated to like someone.  You are obligated to not act like a bratty teenager about it.  You are obligated to admit that they have the right to dress however they damn well please and be subject to the same level of respect as you are.  Slut-shaming is not cool, ever.  Whether a woman is dressed provocatively because she’s portraying a particular character who she really likes, or choosing to do so because she enjoys being able to freely express her sexuality and personal aesthetic preferences, she is still a human being, and deserves to be treated as such.


6 responses »

  1. First off… wow. I am, once more, surprised and disturbed by humans. Playing devil’s advocate, however (I am a gamer girl, myself, keep in mind), if dressing up as our favourite characters means dressing provocatively, what does that say about the game/film/etc. companies creating these toons dressed like this? Is there blame to lay? Is there a point where it crosses a line? NOT at all standing up for the jerks of whom you speak, but do we go too far with sexuality in tv/film/games? Not that I plan to stop wearing low cut blouses anytime soon. They get me out of a lot of speeding tickets. (kidding)

    • In some games and films, yes, we absolutely do. The MMO Tera recently took a lot of heat for their uber-young-looking race of bunny girls — we’re talking no older than 12 in appearance — being able to equip the same metal bikinis and provocative armor sets that the others wore. Then you’ve got the Grand Theft Auto series where the majority of the female characters you’ll interact with are prostitutes, who you can then bludgeon to death with a golf club to get your money back after “doing the deed.”

      The trick is, though, that some of these characters? Actually designed by women. Bayonetta’s character design was granted to us by a female employee of Sega. Sometimes it IS fun to run around pew-pewing in ridiculous costumes we wouldn’t be able to wear in public without getting arrested. When those characters are portrayed, though, as being “dumb but sexy” or “in need of rescuing,” that’s when the line gets crossed. Bayonetta was scantily-clad, but damn if she didn’t kick a severe amount of ass. She was confident, tough, smart, and didn’t need a male protagonist to save her. Hell, she ended up saving HIM.

      So sure, go ahead, give me a shiny G-string, but don’t take away my humanity in return.

      • Speaking of underwear, I have memories of wearing a super-short, tight dress at one con when this guy tried to take a panty shot. I didn’t do anything about it because he was so unstealthy and also so far away from me as to not even get the least bit of my hip in the photo, but also because I thought man … if he knew how much underwear I really had on, he probably wouldn’t have bothered. There was the regular underwear, of course, but you can’t ignore the nylons, the girdle, and the pair of spankies that was holding it all in.

        While some costumes obviously have no support and/or no construction put into them for whatever reason, I can think of quite a few where that sheeyit is built like armor to support the girls, for example.

        So not only is this type of behavior from men painful, embarrassing, obnoxious, disgusting and a whole other boatload of terms, it’s also ironic.

  2. Pingback: In Response to: To See Consent Crushed Before Us: The Lamentations Of Nerd Women (Redux) | My Window

  3. Pingback: Crossing The Design Line: An Indignant Review of Scarlet Blade | Glory to the Tardbunny

Comment on This Ridiculousness

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s